That is the question! Whether ’tis nobler, in the mind, to suffer the tests and projects for outrageous parties…well, lets look at the numbers. I’ve got a buddy who I recently spent a few hours in the car with. Our wives were out of town together, and we didn’t know what to do with ourselves, so we drove to Birmingham to look for a place for him to live. Anyway, while in the car, we got to talking about his financial situation and whether or not it was a good idea for him and his wife to finish college. I asked him about what he ultimately wanted to do with his life, and he said that he would like to start a tree service in either Birmingham of Atlanta, and that his wife loves horseback riding and she would love to make a living at it. He told me that they were both finishing college because it was the wise thing to do. So I tried to help him look at it from a different perspective.
His Scenario:
They will both graduate 2 years from now, with a combined debt load of about $50,000. They have $11,000 in student loans now, so it will cost $39,000 to finish. This debt will then be personal debt that he will be responsible for, and at 7%, the average rate for student loans, he will be paying about $350 per month for the next 15 years and pay just over $24,000 in interest. The justification is that with a college degree, they will be able to get jobs (with a soft “j”) making $15,000 more per year between the two of them, which I dispute. Another number that has to be taken into account is the opportunity cost of attending college. Most people will not be able to have a full time job so between the two of them, they are NOT making the $50,000 they could have made each year for those 2 years.
All of this in plain English means that it will cost $163,000 for them to finish college, with the hopes of making an extra $15,000 per year doing something they don’t really want to do in the first place. So, 11 years to break even.
My Scenario:
What I suggested was that he look at it from another perspective. What if he were to take the $39,000 and used it to start a tree service for himself and get his wife up and running with horse riding lessons, which he says could have her making 2-3K by the end of the summer? Then, the debt is not personal debt, but business debt, meaning a potentially lower interests rate, and no personal liability, assuming he forms an LLC. This is the “out of the box” thinking that I have trained myself in. You see, the first thing you do that is out of the box is the hardest, then it starts getting easier, and it starts getting fun!
Did You Like This Post? Subcribe Here!







July 27th, 2007 at 2:19 pm
Yeah i’ve thought about that a lot. It’s important not to discount the value of having a college education. I know for fact that college has given me, and will continue to give me opportunities that others ( high school graduates) don’t have.
As an entrepreneur I understand that it is very tempting to skip college and go straight to “opening my own business,” but the reality of the matter is that more than 75% of small business fail, and if you fail once, twice, or even three times… you have to face the fact that you’ll need a job somewhere else. You’ll need someone else to employ you, and that is a lot easier with a college education.
Plus the partying, friends, and relationships you make are worth more than $39,000
July 27th, 2007 at 9:54 pm
Rashid! I think we must agree to disagree! But, I’m not saying that NO ONE should go to college, or that college is bad. I’m simply trying to combat the prevailing thought process that without college you will, undoubtedly, fail.
So, I’m writing from my experience, which is that I did not go to college, much to the dismay of my in-laws, and I’m doing alright. And I’m glad I didn’t go!
Thanks for your input! keep it up! Sometimes I need to be kept in check!!! HA!
Graham
July 30th, 2007 at 5:02 pm
Haha,
yeah your right about the whole “prevailing thought process that you are bound to fail”. I definitely agree that college is not the only way to success.
For example: Some people, like you, are gifted and can stand up on their own two feet in the real world, but there are a lot of people who can’t, and they would prefer a desk job w/out having to worry about security and their future. Those people, in my opinion, would be better off in college.
Thanks for responding to my comment!
July 30th, 2007 at 5:05 pm
Yeah, I think we’re on the same page!